Proven strategies
To mitigate
safety risks

Leverage our proven expertise to equip your team to build resilience and mitigate safety risks with proven strategies and tactics for today’s dynamic environment.

How to Spot Coercive Control in Families

When someone in the family has a bad temper, everyone feels the effects. We know which subjects to avoid and when to keep quiet. We can read that person’s mood in an instant, even before they walk into a room and by the way they breathe when they answer the phone. We limit visitors to the house – no one else needs to see the flying plates hitting the wall or someone answering the door in their underwear.

Many people consider this “keeping the peace.” But there’s a difference between keeping the peace and living in fear. And that difference tells us a great deal about coercive control in families.

What the Erie Family Murders Teach Us About Coercive Control

On October 9, 2026, nine people were murdered in a home in Erie, Pennsylvania, my hometown. Among them were a pregnant young woman who was going to give birth in four days, her two small children, her mother, two brothers, and two women who reportedly arrived to help. Her unborn child also died. The suspected killer, her father, Matthew Stone Sr., then took his own life.

The Erie community was stunned by the tragedy. But what investigators subsequently revealed about life inside the household raises a larger question – How long can a family live under a tyrant’s control before outsiders recognize what’s happening?

According to Associated Press reporting on the Erie police investigation, Stone controlled the family’s movements, finances, and contact with relatives. These patterns are called coercive control – the emotional and mental aspects of domestic abuse. Investigators also described a previous domestic violence incident involving a firearm. Although no one can know everything that happened inside that home, we can surmise most of what happened from well-known patterns of control. Investigators have yet to establish a definitive motive for the killings. But the reported circumstances illustrate something that too many families still don’t recognize.

Abuse isn’t always a series of violent incidents. Sometimes it’s an entire system of control.

And that system often operates for years without anyone on the outside understanding what’s happening. In this short video, I explain what investigators reported about the Erie family murders and why recognizing coercive control matters long before physical violence occurs.

What Is Coercive Control in a Family?

Coercive control is a repeated pattern of behavior used to restrict another person’s independence, choices, and freedom. It can include intimidation, isolation, financial restrictions, surveillance, threats, humiliation, or punishment for disobedience. And unlike an occasional argument or disagreement, coercive control creates an ongoing imbalance in which one person imposes consequences on the rest of the family for exercising ordinary independence.

It doesn’t have to involve physical violence, although physical violence may be part of the pattern. And it doesn’t occur only between romantic partners. Parents can control adult children. Adult children can control elderly parents. And other relatives can create households where everyone has to accommodate one person’s demands.

One of the most revealing signs is how the rest of the family behaves. People stop disagreeing. They begin asking permission for ordinary decisions. They carefully manage what information reaches the controlling person.

But the most important and tragic things is that the control becomes so familiar that family members themselves stop recognizing how much their lives have changed…and are controlled. The control has become normalized.

Five Warning Signs of Coercive Control in Families

Most people recognize the obvious signs of domestic abuse: hitting, threatening, screaming, or displaying a weapon. But not many people on the outside recognize the less obvious behaviors.

1. Everyone Walks on Eggshells

One person’s moods determine what everyone else can say or do. Family members constantly monitor facial expressions, tone of voice, and behavior. They change subjects, cancel plans, or warn visitors to avoid certain topics. They may become extraordinarily skilled at anticipating trouble.

From the outside, this can look like cooperation. But these are the hallmarks of coercive control. From the inside, it’s constant threat management.

2. Ordinary Decisions Require Permission

Imagine being an adult who needs permission to visit a friend, buy groceries, spend money, or make a doctor’s appointment.

Or having to explain every purchase because someone else controls the bank account.

A healthy family may discuss shared responsibilities and finances. That’s normal.

But when one person dictates what others may do and punishes independent decisions, we’re no longer talking about ordinary household arrangements.

We’re talking about control.

3. Relationships Outside the Family Begin to Disappear

People stop attending family functions. They don’t return your calls. You hardly ever see them anymore, and they always seem to have an excuse.

Sometimes, the controlling person may explicitly forbid contact. While other times, family members learn that maintaining outside relationships involves so many problems that they gradually stop trying. Isolation doesn’t always need locked doors. Sometimes the consequences of just leaving the house are enough.

4. Personal Information Becomes Ammunition

We expect people who love us to know our fears, insecurities, mistakes, and vulnerabilities. In healthy relationships, that knowledge helps build trust and acceptance. But in controlling relationships, that knowledge becomes leverage. Something shared in confidence is later used to humiliate someone, question their judgment, or pressure them into compliance.

This pattern is particularly important in our work with Irish domestic abuse researcher Don Hennessy, who has spent decades examining how certain skilled abusers learn what matters to their partners and then use that knowledge to control them.

The larger principle extends beyond intimate relationships: Pay attention when someone repeatedly uses personal knowledge against the people who trust them. For more on how criticism can become a tool of control, see our article on mind control in relationships.

5. Disagreement Has Consequences

Every family disagrees. But the difference is what happens afterward. Does someone get angry but eventually work through the disagreement? Or do they intimidate, pressure, punish financially, or threaten surveillance, humiliation, or retaliation? Does everyone know that saying no will cost them something? Because that brings us to the most important question families can ask.

The Question Every Family Should Ask

What happens when someone in this family says NO?

Can an adult daughter disagree with her father without being threatened?

Can a wife spend her own money without explaining every purchase?

Can a grown son visit relatives without consequences?

Can someone leave the house, end a relationship, or ask for help without fearing retaliation?

These questions tell us something that appearances don’t. They tell us whether people are free within their own homes. Of course, a single argument or disagreement doesn’t establish coercive control. In a healthy relationship, there are bound to be disagreements. But the red flags that we’re looking for are repeated patterns of intimidation, restriction, and consequences.

And here’s what’s really important: Don’t assume that because someone appears to cooperate with the abuser, that they’re comfortable with what’s happening.

Why Compliance Doesn’t Mean Agreement

One of the most persistent misconceptions about coercive control is that people who remain in these situations somehow accept what’s happening. In other words, outsiders think that they either don’t know what’s going on or that they’re ok with it.

They might seem cooperative. They may defend the controlling person. They may minimize abuse or withdraw something they’ve previously disclosed. But compliance doesn’t mean consent. Sometimes it means they’ve learned what happens when they resist.

If speaking up brings punishment, then keeping quiet becomes a survival strategy. If disagreeing causes an explosion, agreeing feels safer. And if seeking help leads to retaliation, the person stops asking.

What outsiders interpret as loyalty can sometimes be fear. And what appears to be a family’s private way of doing things may actually be a system that keeps its members trapped. Living this way also consumes enormous mental energy. In our article Why Trauma Impacts Clear Thinking, we explain how constantly anticipating another person’s reactions can turn even ordinary decisions into risk assessments.

Imagine doing that every day, for years. It’s exhausting. And it makes finding a way out even more difficult.

Why Leaving a Controlling Family Can Be Dangerous

One of the most dangerous periods in an abusive relationship can occur when the controlling person believes they’re losing control. That might involve someone preparing to leave, asserting independence, disclosing abuse, or refusing demands. Threats, stalking, previous violence, and access to firearms make these situations particularly concerning.

In the Erie case, investigators reported that Angelina Stone was preparing to leave the household after giving birth. Keep in mind that we can’t conclude that her plans caused the murders, because investigators haven’t established a definitive motive yet. But the larger safety lesson is critical.

When someone begins reclaiming independence from a controlling person, the need for careful safety planning may become more urgent—not less.

This is why families should never assume that confronting the person, demanding explanations, or staging an intervention will resolve the problem. Sometimes those actions can increase the danger.

The National Domestic Violence Hotline offers safety-planning guidance for people facing abuse and those supporting them.

How to Help Someone Experiencing Coercive Control

Suppose you recognize several of these warning signs in someone you love. What should you do?

First, resist the urge to rush in and confront the person you believe is responsible. Your concern may be justified. But the person living in that household knows things that you don’t, including what happens after everyone else goes home. Here are five ways to approach the situation more safely.

1. Speak Privately and Don’t Judge

If it’s safe to talk privately, try asking:

  • “Do you feel safe disagreeing with him?”
  • “What happens when you make a decision he doesn’t like?”
  • “Is there anything you’re afraid might happen if you say no?”

You don’t need to interrogate someone or demand a disclosure. Just start by listening.

2. Don’t Demand an Explanation

Someone living under coercive control may not be ready—or safe enough—to tell you everything. They may be worried about being overheard, monitored, disbelieved, or punished. You can offer support without demanding details. And if they minimize what’s happening, that doesn’t necessarily mean your concerns are wrong.

3. Keep the Relationship Open

Isolation strengthens control. Continued contact, even when someone declines help, can make an enormous difference. Let the person know you’re available. Avoid ultimatums. Don’t make your support conditional on their willingness to leave. The National Domestic Violence Hotline provides additional advice on supporting someone experiencing abuse.

4. Get Professional Guidance Before Intervening

Before arranging transportation, housing, or a confrontation, speak with a domestic violence advocate about the safest next steps. Keep in mind that phones, online accounts, and location-sharing services may be monitored. So even well-intentioned messages can create danger if the controlling person discovers them.

And remember: You can contact a domestic violence organization for guidance even if the person you’re concerned about hasn’t asked for help.

5. Take Threats and Firearms Seriously

Threats to kill, intimidation with weapons, stalking, and escalating violence are not ordinary family disagreements. They require serious attention. If there is immediate danger, call 911. Tell emergency responders about known weapons or threats, and don’t put yourself in danger by approaching or confronting an armed person.

When there isn’t an immediate emergency, a domestic violence professional can help you consider safer options.

Recognizing Coercive Control Before Violence Occurs

In the aftermath of tragedies like the one in Erie, people understandably ask how something so terrible could happen. And sometimes the discussion turns to what relatives, neighbors, or friends should have noticed.

But people living under coercive control may spend years concealing the very behavior that puts them in danger. And those who love them may be trying to help under circumstances we cannot fully understand. In Erie, two women reportedly arrived after Angelina contacted her aunt for help. Their deaths do NOT mean that they were responsible for what happened.

Responsibility for these murders belongs to the man who committed them. Our responsibility now is to learn. We need to recognize that a family can be in serious danger long before someone reports a physical assault. We need to understand that fear can look like obedience, isolation can look like privacy, and silence can look like agreement.

And we need to teach people that helping someone escape coercive control requires more than courage. It requires planning, professional support, and an understanding of the risks. Because a home where everyone must obey one person isn’t necessarily a peaceful home.

Sometimes it’s a home where everyone has learned to survive.

And that’s a difference we can no longer afford to overlook.


Where to Get Help

In Erie, Pennsylvania: SafeNet Erie provides confidential domestic violence advocacy, shelter, counseling, and safety planning. Its 24-hour crisis hotline is 814-454-8161.

Anywhere in the United States: Contact the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 800-799-7233, text START to 88788, or use its confidential online chat.

If someone is in immediate danger, call 911.

If your phone or internet use may be monitored, consider contacting these services from a safer device.


Laura Frombach is an Erie native, U.S. Army veteran, domestic abuse survivor, author, speaker, and co-founder of Street Smart Safety for Women. Her work with retired Deputy Sheriff Joy Farrow and Irish domestic abuse researcher Don Hennessy focuses on helping people recognize patterns of coercive control and reclaim personal safety.

Although examples in this article include men as controlling family members, coercive control can occur across genders and family relationships.

Be The First to Know

We’re launching soon. Join the waitlist and we’ll notify you the moment it’s available.

By signing up, you will also receive occasional updates and offers. You may unsubscribe at any time.